This is the journey and experiences of an American Jew fighting for the State of Israel as a lone soldier in the Israel Defense Forces................................................................................................................... .......................................זהו המסע ואת החוויות של יהודי אמריקאי, נלחם למען מדינת ישראל כחייל בודד של צה"ל
Saturday, December 25, 2010
the Israel Defense Force
Sunday, December 12, 2010
The Final Countdown
Monday, December 6, 2010
Fire and Rain
Monday, November 29, 2010
Hello IDF: TZAV RISHON
Friday, November 26, 2010
Happy Thanksgiving--the view from Israel!
Happy Thanksgiving to all! For the second time in three years I will be out of the country on Turkey Day. Two years ago I was in Ireland, sharing a very pleasant home-cooked meal courtesy of a friend’s friend’s aunt’s friend, complete with a few slices of turkey and the occasional anti-Semitic comment from our elderly Irish host.
Today, I will again have pre-packaged turkey slices, albeit with perhaps the exact opposite of anti-Jewish talk at the dinner table! Instead, dinner discussions don’t question the Jews’ right to exist or have their own state, but instead center on peace prospects, American interests, etc. I terribly hope this post does not seem like a rant. I will try to be as level-headed as possible. At the end, however, I hope you will gain a greater appreciation and deeper understanding of why I am here. Please feel free to leave comments, suggestions, questions, disagreements, etc. at the bottom! Please read and (try to) enjoy!
Where to begin…how about with the current talk of another settlement freeze? Basically, the thinking of each side goes like this: Israel and the Palestinian Authority (PA) were unable to reach an agreement/peace after the previous freeze ended in September; now that construction in East Jerusalem/West Bank has continued, the PA points to it as the primary obstacle to peace; Israel disagrees, contending it honored the previous freeze, and Netanyahu is trying to hold a very shaky and volatile coalition together while toeing the line on whether or not to seek another 90 day freeze; the US has a headache, wants peace, and is willing to provide incentives, namely providing Israel with 20 F-35 fighter planes. There are a lot more specifics and political hurdles (especially in the Knesset, for example, Netanyahu is in such a political bind that he won’t consider accepting until he has written confirmation from Obama about the planes), but for the purpose of this post, the information provided will suffice.
So, now what? Should Bibi (Netanyahu) accept the US offer? Should Israel continue building settlements? If there is another freeze, will there finally, truly be peace?!
My answer: ABSOLUTELY NOT. Why? To borrow a phrase from George Lakoff, “Don’t Think of Settlements!” Israeli construction in East Jerusalem and the West Bank is NOT what is preventing peace. In fact, there is something far more sinister preventing Israelis and Palestinians from signing accords. Unfortunately, what I am about to suggest is virtually taboo in the politically-correct, overly-apologetic, afraid-to-offend Western political culture. The main impediment to peace, the reason there will be no peace, is because the Arabs and Palestinians refuse to accept the right of Jews to live in Israel and would rather die than recognize Israel as a Jewish state.
Sounds extreme, no? But, I assure you, history and the facts add up to this horrific conclusion. In response to Mahmoud Abbas’ call for a new freeze, Bibi, in a politically savvy and promising move, said that he would support a freeze in the Knesset and agree to talks without preconditions if the PA would only recognize the State of Israel; Abbas would get what he wants and Israel would be seen as a legitimate state, nothing more nothing less. Apparently, since making such a claim is anathema to everything that is the Palestinian identity (or at least the PA), Abbas outright rejected the overture. This really made me wonder: if all the core issues ( settlements, Jerusalem, security, refugees) were hammered out, would the Palestinians still refuse to recognize Israel? What the hell does it take for peace?
What peace needs are open-minded people living in a liberal society. Unfortunately, the Palestinian people, courtesy of their leadership, are robbed of both. Take, for example, the case of Walid Husayin, a Palestinian living in the West Bank. His story is currently attracting a lot of attention on Facebook. Why? Because he is suspected of posting an essay called “Why I Left Islam” on an atheist website. The PA has him detained, without seeing visitors of lawyers, since late October (“Free Palestine!” Bret Stephens, Wall Street Journal, November 23, 2010; Stephens also talks more generally about illiberalism in the PA). If the lack of free expression didn’t make you question the Fatah leadership, if the detaining without outside visitors didn’t make you questions the Fatah leadership, consider this: on June 25, 2006, Hamas captured an Israeli soldier named Gilad Shalit. In the 1600 days since, NOT ONE person has been allowed to visit him. I don’t mean family or friends; I mean the Red Cross, UN, Doctors Without Borders…no one! And Hamas is recognized as a terrorist organization.
(In fact, one interesting contrast is how Hamas and Israel view their civilians. One scenario, two different solutions: bombs and rockets are raining down on your city. In Sderot, Israel, children, with less than a minute of warning, are sent to the nearest bomb shelter for protection from Hamas’ rockets. In Gaza, after the Israeli Air Force drops leaflets warning civilians of the buildings that will be attacked, Hamas orders these innocent individuals up to the roofs to become martyrs. One side tries to save lives, the other tries to gain international public relations points. What country has ever done that? What its enemy’s civilian population ahead of time? Israel is indeed a rogue state! Please read: “When Gabriel Latner turned tables on the Israel-bashers,” Jonny Paul, The Jerusalem Post, November 17, 2010)
But, there are plenty of countries that don’t have liberal and law-abiding societies (Iran, North Korea, Saudi Arabia, Burma…clearly your class acts!). Understand that the Palestinian people live in a world where they are fed information and are led to believe realities that are—to be blunt—lies. Take, for example, when the chief Islamic judge of the Palestinian Authority made perhaps the most outrageous and incorrect statements ever uttered: the Jews have no connection to Jerusalem (“Palestinian Leaders Deny Jerusalem’s Past,” Bari Weiss, Wall Street Journal, September 25, 2009). With statements like these coming from the leadership, no wonder no one is jumping to recognize Israel. Please look at Palestinian Media Watch’s (PMW) website and see how young children are led to believe that Jews do not belong in Israel, that martyrdom is the desired path for any Muslim, and a host of other things that, if taught in America’s schools and broadcast on children’s television programs, would receive the biggest outcry. Suddenly, the anger and hostility that culminated in the two intifadahs begin to make sense.
“Hold on a second. I know Palestinians who are good people!” And I do too. I know plenty of Palestinians, Arabs and Muslims who do not wish ill towards anyone, even Jews and Israelis. I honestly believe that most people in the world just want to make a living, keep a roof over their head, bread on the table, and provide for their family. For most of the world, politics is an impediment, not an expedient. But most of the world is not like the free societies of America, Israel and the West. Instead, most people still live under the rule of a regime that is not beholden to its subjects (note I did not say ‘citizens’).
(For a great, albeit brief, analysis of this, please see Lawrence Wright’s My Trip to Al-Qaeda. It is his incredible story getting to know al-Qaeda. I’d like to share one small part here: he likens Saudi Arabia to a hypnotized chicken, a reference to his experience as child when he swung chickens in a circle and they stayed frozen for a few minutes. In Saudi Arabia, you feel like a “guest, not a citizen.” There is no nightlife, no free press, no movies, nothing outside of Islam and the ruling family. By any social scientists standard, Saudi Arabian society is ripe for revolution. But, incredibly enough, the people continue to live their lives…frozen. Why? They stay obedient subjects, not out of love of their dictatorial regime, but rather they look around the region and are afraid of the consequence of rebellion, namely Iraq, Afghanistan, Lebanon.)
But returning to the issue at hand…the man who gave me a tour through East Jerusalem this past weekend commented that settlements account for a quarter of the jobs in the Palestinian territories. True? I haven’t looked into it yet. However, what’s more, in the spring of 2010, PMW’s director Itamar Marcus came to my campus and showed us a few slides about Palestinians’ views of Israeli human rights treatment pre- and post-Oslo. Although I cannot relocate the exact numbers, I recall that upwards of 95% viewed Israeli treatment positively, compared to low 90s or high 80s of the US and France. That number dropped significantly following the Oslo Accords, when the PA began to govern itself. Conclusion? The decreased interaction with Israel/Israelis led to a decreased favorable opinion. Meaning? The PA leadership, especially if its current actions are any indication, likely began disseminating false information about Israel and Jews.
So…to wrap this up…THE SETTLEMENTS CONTROVERSY WILL NOT RESOLVE ANYTHING. What’s at stake here is a fundamental, deep-seated inability and hatred for the Palestinian leadership to live with the reality and existence of a Jewish state. So, what does that mean for me?
It’s like one of the t-shirts here that tourists often buy. It’s black with white writing on the front that lists civilizations with their “status.” It lists Ancient Egypt, Philistines, Assyrian Empire, Babylonian Empire, Persian Empire, Greek Empire, Roman Empire, Byzantine Empire, Crusaders, Spanish Empire, Nazi Germany and Soviet Union…all with “Status: X-Gone.” The only question mark is Iran. Where are the great empires and civilizations of history? They are just that: history. The Jewish civilization remains and thrives!
This new understanding, combined with the incredible Shabbat I had in Jerusalem, simply re-emphasized for me the fact that I am here as a Jew, not an Israeli. I am here because there are people in this world who say I should not be here. I am here to fight against those who say because my mother was Jewish, I am the cause of the world’s evils. I am here to fight, right or wrong, to stay in this land. I am here to fight to exist as a human being—which is never wrong. I am a Jew—and proud of it!
Tuesday, November 23, 2010
Shabbat Shalom!
What a week this has been! Both for Israel and myself, this past week was filled with activity and tumult. In this post, I will first go over the past week of my life, then I will delve into current events a little, and perhaps unavoidably explain my own perspectives on politics in the country and region. Sound like a plan? Great! Hope you enjoy the following…
My first order of “IDF enlistment business” after procuring a visa was to fax it to the Mahal office. This was done simply enough last Wednesday. Now, the information sheet I received after signing my life over states that I will have to wait two to three weeks before Mahal notifies me of my tzav rishon date. Tzav Rishon is a “day of tests” I must undergo so the IDF knows my physical ability, mental acuity, intentions, etc. (I will explain more about it after the fact.) What’s noteworthy for me is that I called Mahal a few hours after faxing my visa to verify they received it (you never really know here), and the soldier who answered the phone confirmed its receipt and said they would contact me next week! So I am expecting a phone call anytime this week. While I am not too optimistic that it will come, I was still shocked to hear of the potentially quick turnaround. There are no further enlistment hurdles to go through after the tzav rishon, so the supposedly lengthy and headache-filled process has turned out to be…shall I say…doable? But, it ain’t over ‘til it’s over…hopefully I didn’t speak too soon.
Anyway, I have had a lot of time on my hands with nothing pressing to do. I contacted a few friends of mine at Ohr Somayach yeshiva (where I was on a three week program this summer) about staying with them for Shabbat. It took me sixteen days after arriving in Israel to finally make it to Jerusalem! But I made the most of it. With my two friends, Ami and Elliot, we walked from the yeshiva to the Old City, via Damascus Gate. Jerusalem’s Old City has about a half dozen gates, really just entrances. Named for cities they face, Damascus gate faces northeast toward the Syrian capital, thus it is in East Jerusalem. Oh my! Not quite. The three of us walked down a major road toward the city. As we neared the medieval walls, we veered toward the gate and passed Arab grocers and vendors, trucks and vans unloading food, and other like-minded Jews preparing to welcome the Sabbath in the Old City.
Crossing a final street, and dodging cabs and motorbikes in the process, we walked down a flight of stairs and joined the Jewish flood through the gate, hearing Arabic and keeping an eye out for trouble all the while. However, Jews are probably safest at that hour; the entrance to Damascus Gate, and the path towards the Western Wall for that matter, is littered with Israeli soldiers and policeman donning bullet proof vests, with M4 rifles at the ready, and eyeing all suspiciously—Jew and Arab. Still, it is difficult to feel safer than that, or more proud for that matter. I know these soldiers are there to keep the peace. In reality, they are likely the only reason that Jews are able, week after week, to pass safely through Arab controlled streets to pray at our holiest sight.
And pray we did! Perhaps the one word to describe Friday night at the Kotel (Western Wall) is “electrifying!” I remember the first time I was there on Birthright last year. I have davened (prayed) there multiple times since, and twice more on Shabbat. I still think the same thing I did that first time in January: what an incredible and humbling feeling to be able to stand in front of Judaism’s holiest site, a place our people have been trying to return to for literally thousands of years, facing persecution, expulsion, and death, the world over, in the process. On Friday night, the entire plaza before the Wall is completely packed with black hats and suits. As we were not with a group, we found a rabbi we knew, assembled a minyan (ten adult men), and began Shabbat with my favorite song: Yedid Nefesh. It’s tune carries such a yearning in it that, at the Kotel, I am able to transport myself through centuries of Jewish struggle and hope. Even before I learned the meaning of the song, I connected to its melody of hope and remembrance. As the sky above the Wall begins to darken, something comes over Jerusalem and the entire notion of Judaism and the purpose behind hundreds of seemingly different people coming to one specific location for their faith becomes…overwhelmingly real.
Briefly, what makes the Kotel so holy and special? It is the western wall of the Temple Mount, upon which once stood בית המקדש Beit Hamikdash: the Holy Temple. The site for the Temple was not random: it is on Mount Moriah, the location of the binding of Isaac, when Abraham was commanded by G-d to sacrifice his son as a test. The site is also the location of אבנ השתייה Even haShetiya, the Foundation Stone, from which the world was created. It is over this exact location that the Jewish people had two temples: King Solomon built the first in 957 BCE and was destroyed by the Babylonians in 586 BCE; the second temple was completed in 515 BCE after twenty-three years of construction, only to fall to the Romans in 70 CE. G-d’s presence, שכינה shechinah, was ever-present during most of this time period. Fast forward two thousand years, and the great walls of the Temple Mount are virtually destroyed (save for the western one) and instead, a golden dome rises above the Temple Mount: the Muslims built the Dome of the Rock in 691 CE. This shrine, to me, is a constant reminder of what we, the Jewish people, lost and have never reclaimed. However, we still believe that G-d’s presence resides on the Western Wall, and thus it maintains its holiness, and is a place where people, religious and secular, from around the world travel to become witness and leave notes of hope between its stones.
For dinner, we were to meet up with a rabbi somewhere on the plaza. Like finding a needle in a haystack, it’s near impossible to pick out one individual from the masses. And, no, you can’t use a cell-phone. Thankfully, we were able to find our host, who led us on a short walk from the Wall to his home—yes, he lives in the Old City. Incredible. After dinner, he brought us to his roof and we could see the entire Old City, including the golden dome, which seemed close enough to touch. The view was unbelievable.
We walked out of the Old City via the Jaffa Gate, in the Jewish side of the city. It’s eerily pleasant walking the streets of Jerusalem on Friday night. There are only a few cars out on the streets and people walk everywhere: to dinner, evening lectures, celebrations, etc. It’s a great feeling to be surrounded by your own people in their rightful place.
The rest of Shabbat was a spiritual journey that I need not describe in detail. There was morning prayer, including reading from the Torah, a festive lunch, afternoon nap, afternoon prayer followed by a third meal and inspirational lecture, then evening prayer after sundown. Ami, Elliot and I had a few beers before I returned to Tel-Aviv. One last great thing about the weekend: a bus ride from my apartment to the center of Tel-Aviv, then a sheyrut (large taxi or van) to Jerusalem, then bus to Ohr Somayach, and back again cost me about $20.
I actually returned to Jerusalem yesterday with Kathryn, a friend from school who’s now living in Israel. We left in the morning and aside from a meeting I had set up with a rabbi at another yeshivah, Aish HaTorah, we had no plan. On the bus to the Old City we actually ran into a guy a few years older from Skokie. Small world. But in Jerusalem, you meet people from all over the world, all concentrated in a small locale, all searching for something.
The meeting at Aish was suggested by one of my mentors from back home, Rabbi Shalom Garfinkle. He commented to me that I may enjoy going there for Shabbat or learning while in the military. Conveniently, actually, while Kathryn and I were there for a half hour, I met a few guys who were joining Mahal as well. I definitely plan on going back for classes or Shabbat before my enlistment. For the rest of the day, we spent some time at the Kotel, enjoyed watching the Sephardi Bar Mitzvah from afar (the whole city could tell there was a Sephardic celebration because of the shrieking women!), ran into one of Kathryn’s many random friends and got a short tour of the Arab quarter, including a visit up to the exit of the Temple Mount (beyond which only Muslims are allowed), got intentionally lost in the Christian quarter, walked to a populated street in the “new” city, meandered our way over to the government buildings, and finally settled at a bar for some beer and hookah. Ami met us, and then an Israeli sat at the table next to us. We introduced ourselves and naturally engaged in friendly conversation. He had just finished his military service that very day. Everywhere I go, people often ask where I’m from and what I’m doing here. He was very excited to hear of my plans and offered a few pieces of advice. If I’m ever in Haifa, he told me, don’t hesitate to call. That’s becoming a common theme among Israelis.
Today, I decided to finally visit some of Tel Aviv’s tourist sites. I first went to David Ben-Gurion’s house. It is a quiet home on Rothschild street; the rooms are adorned with pictures of Ben-Gurion and other heads of states, his expansive library and numerous, insightful quotes. I then biked over to ההגנה, the Haganah Museum. The Haganah was the military organization that protected the Jewish immigrants and settlers before the establishment of the state. After, I went to the Ze’ev Jabotinsky Museum, a few rooms dedicated to one of the early visionaries of Zionism. He was instrumental in helping thousands of Jews escape pre-war Europe on clandestine ships to Palestine. Finally, I went to a diamond museum in Tel Aviv’s diamond district. Israel is a world leader in diamond trading. Blood diamonds? Not at all! Israel was an early signatory, and 2010 chair, to the 2003 Kimberley Process, which seeks to end the use of conflict/blood diamonds.
So, that has been the past week or so. In the coming few days I will make good on my plan to talk about Israeli politics and probably a little more about Israelis and being in Tel Aviv.
Monday, November 15, 2010
One Month!!!
Count it: 30 days until I am finally in uniform for Israel! I am still very excited, and also a bit apprehensive. There are times when I want to be in basic training already and other times when I just want to live the leisure lifestyle I've, unfortunately, become accustomed to over the past six months.
Sunday, November 7, 2010
the First Step
Time for another post. I plan to write every Sunday, even though Sunday in Israel is like Monday in America. Israelis, religious and secular, take time off of work to observe Shabbat from Friday night to Saturday night. People may work for a few hours Friday morning, but most are at outdoor farmers markets or grocery stores, preparing for Shabbat meals. Children have school the morning before Shabbat; the only day off they have is Saturday. Even though schools are open six days a week, they don't have a full day like in the US; children will come home in the early afternoon every day.
Anyway, how am I living in Israel? Where and with whom am I staying? David and Amy Warshawsky have been kind enough to take me in and treat me as family. That has a lot to do with them actually being my family! Technically, David is my second cousin once removed...I think. Our relation is this: my great-grandmother (my mom's mother's mother) and his grandfather (his father's father) were siblings. They lived in Poland before the war. My great-grandmother emigrated to America in the 1930s and David's grandfather was sent to Siberia after Poland was invaded. As a community leader, businessman and former soldier, the Red Army considered him a potential threat. He was the only one in his village to be sent away; the others were not so fortunate. My great-grandmother and David's grandfather were the only ones of six children to survive the war. My grandmother grew up in America, and David's grandfather moved to Palestine after the war and his side of the family became Israeli.
The last time I saw David and Amy was back in Chicago probably when I was six or seven. There has been virtually no contact since then, until I called David this summer, explained my plans, and immediately he said I was more than welcome to live with them and their three daughters: Lina (12), Kaya (9), and Shia (3). Amy reached out to me a few weeks before my flight and said she hopes I consider their home my home and use them as a base for my time here. I have never had to think about living arrangements for months; I can not imagine what I would have done if I did not have this family here. Would I have figured something out? Certainly, I'm not the first chayal boded. Would it have been difficult? Probably. And having something as strong as a family bond between me and my hosts is irreplaceable. David and Amy have truly made their home and family a home away from home.
So earlier today, David and I went to the Mahal office and I finally, officially signed the papers to join TZAHAL!! My enlistment is for December 15th (not the 21st, that was incorrect), with 3 months Ulpan, followed by 5 or 6 months of basic training. I'm still going into Nahal after the Ulpan, with an option to go into Golani or Givati. As David explained to me, those are "serious combat units." He said that I am joining the Marines of the IDF. This isn't going to be any walk in the park. I will do everything that is expected of Israelis; the only difference between me and them is that my service is for a shorter period. I'm excited. I wish I didn't have to do the ulpan and could go straight into basic training, but obviously I do need to know the language.
A good portion of my day is spent studying Hebrew. I use the RosettaStone program they have in the apartment and have built up my vocabulary and comprehension daily. I spaek as much Ivrit as possible around the city. I am completely butchering the holy tongue, but, hey, we all gotta start somewhere, right?! Earlier today, David, Amy and I went to look at locations for Lina's bar mitzvah party. I asked the woman we met with: "Slicha, at et?" Literally: "excuse me, you are a pen?" All three turned to look at me like I'm nuts. David and Amy chimed in, "Shellach et" "Do you have a pen." Still, sensing my American-ness, the woman understood what I meant and gave me a pen.
Another goal of mine right now is to somehow land a job. It's really more to occupy my time and provide me with some extra spending money. Unfortunately, who's going ot hire me for 5 weeks? (5 weeks!!) The one bar I already stopped in said that I have to be a citizen to work there. Maybe I can find a babysitting job with David and Amy's friends.
The rest of my day is/will be devoted to exercising to get physically prepared. I run a few blocks north to a river, turn west for a couple kilometers until I reach the Mediterranean Sea, then I can go as far south as I want. It's incredible weather; I can exercise outside at all hours of the day, and nighttime is very pleasant: the humidity drops and temperature cools to mid-70s. Also along these running paths are workout stations that seem at once odd and also surprisingly convenient. Every few miles is a little area with simple machines that use body weight as a resistance. They are along running paths, the beach, parks, etc. Very Israeli.
But perhaps the most Israeli thing to happen to me so far was before I even landed in this country. On the plane ride over (Eric: Toy Story 3 and Surrogates), I was seated next to a couple my parents age. We conversed at the beginning and end of the flight and I explained how I was joining Tzahal as a chayal boded. Before we landed, they gave me their contact information, explained how they also had a son who is joining soon, and told me not to hesitate to call if I needed a place to stay or a warm meal. A guy a few years older than me sitting across the aisle gave me his number and said to call if I wanted to know of places to go out at night in Tel-Aviv. A couple a few rows behind me lives in West Rogers park (Jewish neighborhood in Chicago) and the husband gave me his number and told me to call when I'm in the area. Even though I mentioned that it might be a few years, he said no worries, just look him up whenever I get back. Finally, the cab driver who drove me to David and Amy's place, after a long conversation ranging from politics to America to the military to complaining about morning rush hour traffic, gave me his business card as he knows people who help out chayalim bodedim. Where else do you find this kind of support? Generosity? Kinship? Only perhaps in Israel and with the Jewish people. It's incredible.
I've been tagging along with David and Amy the past few days as they run errands. I've gotten to know the city pretty well in just a few days. Wherever we go, they introduce me as their cousin and explain that I am here to join the military. Everyone is impressed and gracious. Truth be told, there was one friend who looked at me in bewilderment, but on the whole, everyone has been appreciative of my desire to enlist.
Anyway, that's my life here for right now. The other day I took David's bike and biked to the coast (not of Lake Michigan, but the Mediterranean!), turned left, and biked along miles of beach front, through Tel-Aviv and into Jaffa/Yafo. The Arab city isn't like East Jerusalem; it's safe to visit, there is Hebrew (and tourists) everywhere. It used to be a major port city, back in the day. Now the two cities are essentially merged, although it is clear where one ends and the other begins. One the way back, I stopped somewhere along the beach and went for a short swim. The lack of swimmers in the area and plethora of surfboards surprised me, but the mystery was made clear after I got out of the water when I saw a couple signs saying no swimming in the area. And by "saying" I really mean there was a picture of a swimmer with a line through it. I have no freakin idea what it said. Then I grabbed a beer at a beach restaurant and headed back home. What a life!
ISRAEL FUN FACT: In addition to having the world's largest reverse osmosis desalination plant (although not as large as Saudi Arabia's thermal-based desalination plants, Israel's Ashkelon's Seawater Reverse Osmosis (SWRO) plant requires less energy and is more environmentally friendly), Israel reuses 70% of its water!
Friday, October 29, 2010
Shalom Aleichem שלום עליכם
Shalom to my family and friends! I see you have found my blog. I will use this page to keep you updated about my life over the next twenty months. Twenty months?! Yes, this journey/experience/life quest/fool's errand will take me nearly two years. This first entry may be a bit lengthy because I will explain everything about my decision to join the IDF.
A quick update: I leave for Israel on NOVEMBER 2ND, at 10:47am and arrive in Tel-Aviv at Ben-Gurion airport at 8:15am on November 3rd. Thus begins the next stage of my life.
How did I get to this point? Why am I, a Latin honors college graduate, going to fight for a foreign country in the world's powder keg? Read on and even if you do not agree with everything I write, hopefully you will understand and respect my decisions.
My path to the Israel Defense Forces began as an interest in the US military. I spent the summers after my freshman and sophomore years living and working in Washington, DC. Already an ardent patriot, living in the capitol of the greatest country in the world (hubris? NO!) had an incredible impression on me. I would walk by the monuments and read the words of our greatest presidents and feel a fire being kindled inside of me to to serve this land. Like my father, I am a huge history and military buff, and one thing I came to realize is that I live in an extraordinary time: even though it is compulsory for me to sign up for the draft, in reality, I will never have to join the military unless I volunteer. It is a luxury virtually unmatched in world history! Joining the military is uncommon for a Jewish boy from the Chicago suburbs in the 21st century, but not unremarkable for millions of young men (and women) across the world and throughout history.
These thoughts were all fine and good (noble and idealistic) until I told my parents, who responded with skepticism and concern. I think Eric (my brother) even laughed, thinking it would be another thing I would eventually lose interest in, like the guitar, biking...and break dancing. (I recently showed Kimberly, my sister, the "I Am Israel" link on the right, and after watching it, she said she began to understand why.)
Anyway, I forged ahead with my new life choice and started researching options for the Army. I wanted to join the Reserves, which had a minimal two year commitment or the full six years if I wanted them to pay for Law or Graduate school. I did a lot of research online about enlistment options (whether to go to OCS [Officer Candidate School] or enlist as a private, etc) and even spoke to a recruiter. I began my senior year intending to join the US Army upon graduation.
In August, I started to take Arabic, as it is beneficial for a career in international relations. In class, surrounded by Muslims and Arabs, I felt self-conscious about being Jewish. As a blessing in disguise, Arabic pushed me back to Judaism. I began to attend events at Hillel and learn with rabbis about Judaism. Save for Rosh Hashanah, Yom Kippur, lighting Hanukkah candles, or Pesach sedars, I had not done anything "Jewish" since my Bar Mitzvah, ten years ago. I read vigorously about Israel and the conflicts, but that never compelled me to understand the religious identity of Israel and myself.
My learning that fall semester rekindled my love of Judaism and I began to think about joining the IDF. However, my initial enthusiasm was cut short when a professor mentioned that I may as well kiss my State Department aspirations goodbye. I then pushed the IDF out of my mind.
Over New Years, Eric and I went on Birthright. This was a transition point for me because I was now able to see, smell and touch religious and historical Israel. I went to the Golan Heights and viewed the border with Syria, went to the Dead Sea and was a stone's throw from Jordan, climbed Masada, prayed at the kotel (Western Wall) in Jerusalem, and cried at Yad Vashem. This grounded my learning of a far-off place and abstract ideas into a reality I now feel is imperative to defend to the last. I strongly reconsidered the IDF.
The spring semester witnessed a lot of political turbulence regarding Israel. On campus, there were numerous rallies and demonstrations in which students and professors alike decried Israel's "apartheid" society, "genocidal" policies, and "human rights violations." I was active on the front lines against these slanderous accusations. On my own, I was still wrestling with joining the IDF. Over spring break, I flew to DC to interview for jobs after graduation. At some point after the break and before graduation, I knew that I would be joining the IDF.
So, WHY am I joining? Here is a list of my reasons (not in any particular order):
• I want to fight for the Jewish people. One thing my time at U of I taught me was that there are plenty of people out there who not only do not like Jews, but deny them the right to exist. I take great exception to anyone who says that because of my religion, I have no right to breath the same air as anyone else. I want to fight back against those individuals.
• I may make aliyah (literally 'ascent', immigration) one day and every Israeli man and woman has to serve. I do not want to be in the class of society (cough Americans cough) that enjoy the privileges and honor of citizenship without paying their dues and fighting for the country.
• I will regret not joining for the rest of my life. My parents and sister pleaded with my to use my talents and knowledge to fight for Israel and the Jewish people in another capacity, such as diplomacy. Well, I will, just not right now. Now I can serve using my body, later I will serve using my mind.
• Many of the positions I looked for in DC listed military experience as a qualification. It certainly gives me a first hand view of the conflict, as opposed to an observer sitting 6,000 miles away.
• And also, when I was sitting at a desk in DC, I realized how much I did not want to be doing that while I’m still young.
I went back to Israel for three weeks during this summer on a religious trip. One day, I went to the IDF office in Tel Aviv and talked with them about joining. Finally (I know!), here are the logistics of my service:
I am joining the Israel Defense Forces as a Mahal recruit, with chayal boded status. MAHAL is an acronym that means 'overseas volunteer.' The concentration camp inmates who first came to Palestine and were immediately sent to the front lines to fight for the creation of a Jewish state were the initial MAHAL. Chayal boded means 'lone soldier.' I am lone because my immediate family resides outside of Israel. The primary requirements to join the IDF as a non-Israeli is to be Jewish and between 18 and 24. Israel is perhaps the only country in the world that allows non-citizens to fight in its military.
My service is for 18 months, beginning on December 21st. Do I (need to) speak Hebrew? In reality, English is the unofficial official third language of the country (after Hebrew and Arabic). Still, as Hebrew is necessary to know in the military, the first three and a half months of my service is Ulpan (Hebrew language learning). I report (so far as I know) to Carmiel base in the north, where I receive a uniform and am considered an enlisted soldier. Not until after the Ulpan, however, do I begin basic training.
After basic training, most Mahal soldiers are sent to Nahal. There are units I can 'try out' for, such as Givati and Golani Brigade. If I want to try for other elite units, I would have to extend my service. You can find more information about these units with the links at the side of the page.
I leave on Nov 2nd because the IDF requires me to start the enlistment process very early. This includes signing papers, getting medical clearance, obtaining a visa, registering as a lone soldier, etc. Seven weeks plus eighteen months. However, as a lone soldier, the IDF does give me a full month leave to come home. I won't know when that will be until well into my service.
Well, if you made it this far, I appreciate it. Hopefully you now have a much better understanding of what I am doing and why. Feel free to leave any comments or questions and I will do my best to respond.